Shunt Regulator Improves PA's Current-Limit Accuracy
Figure 1. A small-signal transistor (Q2) provides an output current limit for this power amplifier.
Unfortunately, the base-emitter voltage of the small-signal transistor sets the current-limit threshold for this circuit. That VBE has a well-known temperature coefficient of -2mV/°C, which causes a substantial change in current limit across the operating temperature range.
An adjustable shunt regulator (U1 in Figure 2) is preferable to the small-signal transistor for sensing current. This IC is chosen for its low-input threshold (0.6V), which is lower than that of common shunt regulators (1.25V to 2.5V). In addition, the IC's separate power-supply input allows it to maintain accuracy as the internal output transistor approaches saturation.
Figure 2. Substituting a shunt regulator (U1) for Q2 in the Figure 1 circuit improves the current-limit accuracy.
Figure 3 compares current-limit accuracies of the small-signal-transistor version of Figure 1 with the shunt-regulator version of Figure 2. The transistor version exhibits a 25% change in current-limit threshold over the operating temperature range, while the shunt-regulator provides better than 2% accuracy over that range (neglecting the temperature coefficients of the sense resistors).
Figure 3. Current-limit accuracy versus temperature for the circuits of Figure 1 (top trace) and Figure 2 (bottom trace).
A similar article appeared as a Design Idea in the February 2, 2006 edition of EDN.