Effects of Different Resistor Tolerances in a Differential ADC for THD Performance
The MAX11905 is a 20-bit, fully differential SAR analog-to-digital converter (ADC) that samples at 1.6Msps. Picking the lowest tolerance resistor at the input can achieve the best THD performance. But, what if the lowest tolerance is not cost effective? Will the THD be reasonable if a higher tolerance resistor is selected? To answer these questions, we will perform a design test and note the findings in this application note.
Analog Front-End (AFE)
The analog front-end (AFE) consists of a half-gain stage using the MAX44205 differential amplifier. Six resistors are used on the differential amplifier and two additional resistors are required at the MAX11905’s inputs. Figure 1 shows the ADC’s input circuit. By changing the tolerance of the eight resistors, we see the change in THD.
Figure 1. ADC input circuit.
Test Condition for the Analog Inputs and ADC
Table 1 and Table 2 show the power supplies and voltage reference in the design for the test.Table 1. MAX11905 Voltage Supplies and Reference Input
|MAX11905 SUPPLIES||VOLTAGE (V)|
Table 2. MAX44205 Voltage Supplies
|MAX44205 SUPPLIES||VOLTAGE (V)|
A close-to-full-scale 10kHz sine-wave input is applied at the MAX44205's analog inputs. We collected 32,768 samples at the 1.5Msps sampling rate. The equipment and the system were set up for coherent sampling to achieve the THD results.
Table 3 displays the THD for the resistor's tested tolerances. Also included in the table is the cost multiplier for each resistor using ±5% as the base tolerance.Table 3. THD Performance for Different Resistor Tolerances
|RESISTOR TOLERANCE (%)||THD (dB)||COST FACTOR|
|±5 (base)||-108||x 1|
Because the AFE consists of eight resistors, the cost multiplies by the number of resistors on the board of the design. If the design requires the ±0.05% tolerance resistors, the resistors' cost factor is 360 compared with 8 in the design with ±5% tolerance resistors.
Designers need to understand the cost involved when changing resistor tolerance on the AFE. The expected THD performance is based on what the designer is willing to spend since there is a budget for every design.