Squelch in ISM-RF Receivers

By:  Martin Stoehr, Principal Member of the Technical Staff, Applications
© Jun 25, 2012, Maxim Integrated Products, Inc.

Abstract: Many industrial/scientific/medical (ISM) band radio frequency (RF) receivers use a simple external data slicer to generate the baseband digital output. These simple baseband systems can generate unwanted digital output when there are no active radio transmissions. This tutorial provides a basic description of squelch and gives examples for how to implement it in an amplitude-shift keying (ASK)/on-off keying (OOK) or frequency-shift keying (FSK) system.

Click here for an overview of the wireless components used in a typical radio transceiver.
Click here for an overview of the wireless components used in a typical radio transceiver.

Radio Squelch

Squelch is the process of removing unwanted background noise from a receiver in a way that allows for a strong signal to be decoded while weak signals near the level of the receiver's sensitivity are rejected. A common example is available on most walkie-talkies or citizen band (CB) radios where an adjustment knob can increase the squelch level and suppress unwanted audio noise when no transmission in detected. Similarly in a digital radio system, squelch can be used to suppress unwanted digital output or toggling on the data line when no detectable transmission is present. "Breaking squelch" is a common term used to indicate that a received signal has risen above the power threshold, and thus indicates a strong enough transmission is present.

Baseband Decoding

All of Maxim's industrial/scientific/medical (ISM) radio-frequency (RF) receivers include simple baseband-decoding hardware that consists of a Sallen-Key data filter, a comparator or data slicer, and at least one peak detector. Often times the peak detectors go unused, but they can be a convenient way of increasing the responsiveness of the baseband decoding of an initial incoming transmission.
The data slicer is the heart of the baseband system and is used to convert the demodulated analog signal into a digital signal for use by the microcontroller or other digital decoding unit. The common configuration used with a data slicer is to have the baseband analog signal connected to the positive input of the comparator, while the negative input is connected to a lowpass filtered version of the same analog signal. Figure 1 shows a typical schematic of a baseband system with a scope plot that depicts the signals commonly found on the respective pins.
Figure 1. Example circuit and data slicer scope traces.
Figure 1. Example circuit and data slicer scope traces.
Simulated versions of the baseband circuit can be used to show various responses of the system. When a simple resistive-capacitive (RC) slicer level is implemented, there are a few limitations that will impact the accuracy of the output data (Figure 2 and Figure 3).
Figure 2. Oscilloscope plot of data slicer.
Figure 2. Oscilloscope plot of data slicer.
Figure 3. Simulation of a data slicer.
Figure 3. Simulation of a data slicer.
By introducing a peak detector, the output data line can react to the first bits received by "jumping" the slicing threshold to a higher level very quickly (see Figure 4).
Finally, with the use of both maximum and minimum peak detectors, the threshold is quick to reach the center of the baseband signal and thus can respond to the first data bit received and has the best response for accurate duty cycle of the data output signal, as seen in Figure 5.
Figure 4. Simulation of a maximum peak-detect circuit.
Figure 4. Simulation of a maximum peak-detect circuit.
Figure 5. Simulation of maximum/minimum peak-detect circuit.
Figure 5. Simulation of maximum/minimum peak-detect circuit.

Implementing Amplitude-Shift Keying (ASK) Squelch

Adding squelch to an ASK or on/off keying (OOK) system involves offsetting the threshold voltage from where it would normally settle, based on noise power alone. This offset process is commonly accomplished by adjusting the slicing level with the use of a fixed voltage-divider circuit. In Figure 6, the DSN line is pulled up slightly to the supply rail with a 200kΩ resistor. This design was implemented with a potentiometer (R5) which, if populated in exchange for the R6 pullup resistor, would permit the user to manually adjust the amount of positive offset applied to the DSN line.
Figure 6. An example ASK squelch circuit.
Figure 6. An example ASK squelch circuit.
The advantage of this method is the simple reduction or elimination of any "chatter" or unwanted digital output. Unfortunately there are two possible negative impacts. The first is a slight reduction in receiver sensitivity. This comes from the direct trade-off between having the output data constantly reacting to the analog signal based on an average comparison voltage versus adjusting that level so that noise does not cause data transitions. The second impact is a slight skewing of the digital output signal's duty cycle. The change in duty cycle is a result of not having a slicing level that is an exact average between a peak and valley of the analog output. To some extent, using a Manchester-encoding scheme can eliminate this issue.

Implementing Frequency-Shift Keying (FSK) Squelch

Whereas ASK squelch is an easy process to implement with most inherent receiver baseband architectures, FSK squelch is a different matter. In an ASK system, the slicing level will tend to settle at the average noise level because of the method used to establish a comparison signal. In an FSK system, the baseband is configured the same as an ASK system, but the noise profile is different. With an FSK decoder, the noise spectrum will tend to be white (flat across all frequencies), but the IF filter and the receive signal strength indicator (RSSI) limiting amplifiers have undue influence on the average frequency of that noise. Because of tolerances inherent in the system, the average noise output could move the comparison voltage either above the mark and space midpoint or more likely below. Because squelch is inherently related to the strength of the incoming signal, users need to incorporate the RSSI output in the squelch system.
A basic design for FSK squelch requires a system that reacts to an RSSI level, has a reference with which to compare the level, and somehow gates the original digital data. In essence, the RSSI level is compared to a reference voltage. If the incoming signal power is above the break level, then the original data is allowed to pass through the system. This can be accomplished with many different methods, especially when considering the wide variety of microcontrollers available to manage the radio system. An example of a simplified circuit is shown in Figure 7. This is a basic FSK squelch circuit implemented with a matched pair of bipolar junction transistors (BJTs), three resistors, and a capacitor.
Figure 7. A simple FSK squelch circuit.
Figure 7. A simple FSK squelch circuit.
The differential pair is wired as a comparator with VREF and RSSI as inputs to each base. The DATA line is connected as an on/off current source, resulting in a circuit that executes a simple AND gate function. By providing a reference level at VREF (from a basic resistor-divider or digital-to-analog converter (DAC)) the signal at SQDATA is an RSSI-gated version of the DATA line.
Similar to the ASK squelch system, the advantage is a reduction or elimination of "chatter" in exchange for a slight reduction in receiver sensitivity. Since this additional circuit does not directly influence the slicing level of the comparator, the FSK squelch has no impact on the digital output signal's duty cycle. Due to variations in DC offset of the amplified RSSI level, VREF may need to be adjusted individually.

Related Application Notes

Related Parts
MAX1470 315MHz Low-Power, +3V Superheterodyne Receiver Free Samples  
MAX1471 315MHz/434MHz Low-Power, 3V/5V ASK/FSK Superheterodyne Receiver Free Samples  
MAX1473 315MHz/433MHz ASK Superheterodyne Receiver with Extended Dynamic Range Free Samples  
MAX7030 Low-Cost, 315MHz and 433.92MHz ASK Transceiver with Fractional-N PLL Free Samples  
MAX7031 Low-Cost, 308MHz, 315MHz, and 433.92MHz FSK Transceiver with Fractional-N PLL Free Samples  
MAX7032 Low-Cost, Crystal-Based, Programmable, ASK/FSK Transceiver with Fractional-N PLL Free Samples  
MAX7033 315MHz/433MHz ASK Superheterodyne Receiver with AGC Lock Free Samples  
MAX7034 315MHz/434MHz ASK Superheterodyne Receiver Free Samples  
MAX7036 300MHz to 450MHz ASK Receiver with Internal IF Filter Free Samples  
MAX7042 308MHz/315MHz/418MHz/433.92MHz Low-Power, FSK Superheterodyne Receiver Free Samples  

Next Steps
EE-Mail Subscribe to EE-Mail and receive automatic notice of new documents in your areas of interest.
Download Download, PDF Format (477kB)  
Other Channels  Email this page to an associate or friend. 

The content on this webpage is protected by copyright laws of the United States and of foreign countries. For requests to copy this content, contact us.

APP 5428: Jun 25, 2012
TUTORIAL 5428, AN5428, AN 5428, APP5428, Appnote5428, Appnote 5428